Shirah Vollmer MD

The Musings of Dr. Vollmer

The Politics of Psychotherapy

Posted by Dr. Vollmer on February 2, 2017

Image result for politics

How do you teach psychotherapy? What does it mean to supervise? Who should teach psychotherapy? I am involved with this question at both psychoanalytic institutes where psychoanalysis is taught and in psychiatric residencies where psychiatrists are taught. In both institutions, the teaching is done by those willing to teach, and not necessarily by the best teachers. Further, as with all work environments, friends are tapped first, again based on personal relationships and not necessarily based on what is best for students. And despite my continued plea for humility in this field, the sad truth is that we don’t know how to teach it, and student satisfaction is no proof of good teaching. Like psychotherapy itself, we have no clear guidelines about what to do and we have no clear guidelines about how to measure our effectiveness. My answer, not surprising to my readers, is to accept that psychotherapy is an art, and as such, those who choose to enhance themselves our signing up for art school, learning ideas and concepts, but no firm path to doing the work. Further, I value my credentials and I think those are important, and as such, those who teach, in my opinion, should have completed training programs which are recognized by the field, such that dynamic psychotherapy should be taught by graduates of psychoanalytic institutes since they have spent hours reading and discussing psychoanalytic concepts, and without this rigor, the depth of discussion is limited. Yet, since teaching is mostly a volunteer activity, few leaders want to impose restrictions, and so quality control is often sorely lacking. Politics is everywhere. Friends take care of their friends, and so opportunities are shared, sometimes to the detriment of students. Navigating around these waters is the art of life. Recognizing that merit based promotion is often rivaled by cronyism. We help our patients wrestle with these ideas, and so as therapists, we should understand it. I think we do, but it is still a challenge.

2 Responses to “The Politics of Psychotherapy”

  1. Shelly said

    So when your patients are looking for a psychotherapist, what are they looking for? Do they look for credentials, where their therapist graduated from and got their analytical licenses from? If and where they taught at? Do they ask their friends for recommendations? Do they go to their HMO and see who is covered? I totally understand that you are looking for value and integrity in your profession. But if you look at it from your patients’ perspective, look to see what is first and foremost in their minds: Is it covered? Are you the best in your field? Are you a good investment and can you help?

    • Thanks, Shelly. Marketing psychotherapy is an art that as far as I know is poorly understood. Fees, of course, are critical, but so is the internet interface as well as word of mouth. Quality is hard to measure, and as such, it is hard to know what metric to use to pick a therapist and/or a psychiatrist. In general, people refer to their friends, which may or may not be a good fit for the prospective patient, and so that can be a tricky matter. I work in a field with tremendous uncertainty such that if a professional sounds certain, that can be very compelling at first, but ultimately not helpful. Embracing humility is not sexy, and so although that is an important tool in therapy, it is not a good tool for marketing. There is a lot to think about here. Thank you, as always, for chiming in.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: