Shirah Vollmer MD

The Musings of Dr. Vollmer

Head-Meds For Kids…Or..Medicine for the Child’s Mind?

Posted by Dr. Vollmer on September 22, 2015

Aggregate Logo

 

May 6, 2016,  I am booked. Geez, that is advanced planning. Three hours, I have, to discuss medicating kids to mental health professionals dedicated to working with children. As usual, I expect to gain far more than I give, as this audience are folks who have spent years fine-tuning their skills to work with disadvantaged youth who struggle with coping with their circumstances. Nature and nurture will be discussed heavily, as the decision to medicate a child is never easy, simple, or straight-forward. The decision is made after a thorough history, but whose history? The parents, the child, another clinician, or all of the above? Yet, my first order of business is generating a title. I have a series of lectures which begin with Medicines for the…fill in the blank. Originally, I kept a similar title for all of my talks as a way of picturing my book on psychopharmacology for the lay public. Each talk was a chapter in my book, such that “Medicines for the Mind” was the large title and then there was “Medicines for the Female Mind”, “Medicines for the Old Mind,” and “Medicines for the Child’s Mind.” Yet, as the book has receded in my task list, and, as a patient once said to me, “you want to know about my head meds,” I began to think about changing my title. My next lecture on adult psychopharmacology will be entitled “Head Meds” but for my “kiddy talk” I will stick with “Medicines for the Child’s Mind.” I want to emphasize that the complexity of working with children is that their minds evolve as time goes on, such that all practitioners are made humble in that we never know whether we had an impact or maturation finally kicked in. I suppose the same is true of parenting. Parents take credit for “how well their children turned out,” when, in fact, it could very well be that their brain was developing in a non-linear fashion such that the child surprisingly became a responsible adult. Oh, so we return to nature vs. nurture, in which I will say that if the child does well it is nurture, and if he does not, it is nature. I hope I will get a laugh.

2 Responses to “Head-Meds For Kids…Or..Medicine for the Child’s Mind?”

  1. Shelly said

    “Medicines for the Child’s Mind” is still so controversial. To those of us who do medicate, we never get over the guilt and are constantly defending ourselves to other parents, to teachers, to professionals and even to other family members. What kinds of things will you be presenting in your “kiddy talk?” When you say that parents take credit for “how well their children turned out,” does that mean medicated kids or non-medicated ones? Kids with therapy or non?

    • Shelly, you raise an interesting point which I will try to incorporate into my presentation. My hope is that the treating physician works with parents to diminish the guilt, if there is any I think that one day parents will feel less guilty about medicating their kids, as we are still in the early phase of this intervention. Parents usually don’t feel guilty about giving their diabetic children insulin, and so the same should be true for kids with behavioral issues.
      I mean that when children turn out well, somehow the parents take credit, and to me, that is non-linear. This would be true if the kid was on medication, or not. Likewise if the kid runs into developmental issues or behavioral issues, then the default is to blame the parents and/or the medication that the child took. These are retrospective analyses, and as such, this is more about confirmation bias, meaning that parents have pre-conceived notion about what their role is, and then they confirm their thinking based on what the child does. In other words, looking to the medication, or looking to the parenting style is an easy way to avoid the complexity of development. Thanks, as always.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: