Shirah Vollmer MD

The Musings of Dr. Vollmer

Daniel Pearl: Ten Years Later-The Grief Never Ends

Posted by Dr. Vollmer on January 31, 2012

David Remnick, the editor of the New Yorker spoke at the Daniel Pearl Memorial lecture,, marking ten painful years since the unbearable torture and subsequent death of Daniel Pearl. What moved me was not Mr. Remnick, although he was an excellent and charismatic speaker, was the Israeli Dr. Judea Pearl, the  grieving father of Daniel Pearl. I have no relationship with the Pearl family, and yet, as Professor Pearl spoke about his son “Danny” I felt very connected to him. Here was an extremely intelligent man, Judea Pearl, speaking about his disbelief that anyone would want to hurt his precious son. Clearly he knew how dangerous Danny’s job was. Clearly he knew that after 9/11, our world had changed. As an Israeli, he must have also understood terrorism-the randomness of horror. Yet, he said so sweetly, that he just could not imagine that Danny would not return home. I was so moved by what I perceived to be his grief; his agony over trying to understand how this could happen.

     Before the lecture there was a montage, like a celebration, where pictures from Danny’s life were flashed on the screen. There was Danny, the little boy and there was Danny the classical musician. There was Danny’s wedding and there was Danny a little boy again. After that moving introduction to this lecture, it was hard to focus on the following three introductions which ultimately led up to David Remnick’s talk on free speech and the future of journalism. I managed to understand that from Mr. Remnick’s point of view, we live in a good news, bad news environment when it comes to the media. The good news is that the internet has created free speech like we have never had before. The bad news is that no one wants to pay for investigative journalism and so in-depth coverage is likely to be sparse. Yet, my mind kept returning to the Pearl family. There is no good news for them. Sure, his wife was pregnant at the time, and they are the proud grandparents. Sure, the world mourns Daniel’s loss with them, so maybe they don’t feel quite so alone. Still, to be in their presence, even amidst the  four hundred other audience members, is to feel the unbearable grief of a parent. Words fail to describe the feeling. At the same time, the series is about how Daniel Pearl believed in the power of words to make the world a better place. Both are true.

3 Responses to “Daniel Pearl: Ten Years Later-The Grief Never Ends”

  1. Shelly said

    It must have been amazing to have been in the presence of the Pearl family and to listen to the humble words of Judea Pearl. It strikes me how naive he must have been to have believed, as an Israeli, that nobody would have wanted to have hurt his prescious son. Israelis always live with the reality that someone wants to kill us. As Americans and as Israelis (as Daniel Pearl was), we are as good as dead if we end up in the hands of kidnappers. I wonder why and how Judea Pearl became emeshed in the payment for investigative journalism fight? It sounds like someone took advantage of this innocent family to play up on their own agenda. Hasn’t this family suffered enough?

  2. Of course, I am speculating, as free speech allows me to do, and as such, I don’t think Judea Pearl was/is naive, but rather I think that his parental passion overshadowed his understanding of the vulnerabilities in our world. If we think that our children are vulnerable, then it would be hard to get up every morning and attend to the duties of daily living. We have to believe that our children have a guardian angel, no matter how much that contradicts the reality of the world. I don’t think anyone took advantage of this family. On the contrary, I think they are keeping Daniel’s memory alive by reminding the world about the importance of free speech. Thanks, as always.

  3. Elefant said

    The year 2001 should not be repeated

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: